August 2024, Kolkata: The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is trying to provide polygraph tests to four hospital employees in the context of a current twist in the investigation into the sudden passing of a postgraduate trainee (PGT) doctor at Kolkata’s RG Kar Medical College and Hospital. This finding corresponds with the CBI’s stepped-up efforts to determine the root cause of the mysterious and terrible death that occurred earlier this month. The aim of the lie detector tests is to identify any inconsistencies in the subjects’ testimonies, since the CBI believes that the subjects might have vital information with regard to the events surrounding the crime.
The Incident: A Shocking Discovery
On August 9, early in the morning, a PGT doctor’s body was found inside a hospital classroom. The medical community was shocked by the discovery. After completing a late-night shift, the victim was allegedly assaulted and murdered by Kolkata Police civic volunteer Sanjoy Roy while she lay unconscious in the lecture room. Roy was taken into custody the next day, but further research discovered a more sophisticated and maybe deeper system.
Roy reportedly reached the lecture hall at approximately 4:03 a.m. and departed by 4:32 a.m., according to CBI sources, who indicate the crime happened between 4:15 and 4:40 a.m. At 4:37 a.m., he drove from the hospital premises on a motorcycle. There are questions about Roy’s possible accomplices and the deliberate planning of the crime, given the sequence of events reconstructed using CCTV footage and other evidence.
The Suspects: Who Are They?
Four individuals who were in the hospital while the crime took place are the focus of the CBI’s investigations. These include an intern, a member of the house staff, and two first-year trainee doctors. Several situations led to the decision to have these individuals undergo polygraph tests, including the fact that their fingerprints had been discovered in a lecture hall and that they had been near the crime scene.
Source: Hindustan Times Bangla News
1. The two professional trainees are: On the night of the incident, these healthcare providers showed up for the victim. In their own words, they watched the Olympic Javelin Final in the seminar room while enjoying dinner with the victim at roughly midnight. The three decided to have a nap in the seminar room after the sporting event since the sleep room was occupied. The victim chose to stay in the classroom for the lecture; nevertheless, the two residential physicians claim that they left between 1:30 and 2:00 a.m. to attend to patients. Suspicions were raised, however, when their fingerprints turned up in the room where the victim eventually turned up dead.
2. The House Staff Member: Although assigned to the first-floor emergency ward, this individual was caught on video making a trip to a lecture hall on the third floor at around 2:45 a.m. It was claimed that he went again to the first floor someplace between 3:30 and 3:45 a.m. His visit to the third floor during those critical hours and whether or not he spoke with the victim have been examined by the CBI.
3. The Assistant: The victim had conversed with the intern, who was also on the third floor, before she retreated to the seminar room to rest. He says, like the others, that he heard nothing strange at the time of the incident. Why none of the four people heard any disturbance, regardless of whether they were right next to the lecture room, is of great significance to the CBI.
Inconsistencies and Suspicions
The apparent inconsistencies in the statements that these individuals provided led the CBI to make the choice to request polygraph investigations. A significant issue to think about is why the hospital authorities were alerted by the trainee physician who discovered the body instead of the other people who were on the floor. The CBI thinks that these individuals may have been involved in a cover-up or that the victim might have been silenced.
Source: India today
In addition, while health records and DNA evidence have yet to prove an unambiguous link between these individuals and the crime, the CBI believes that they may have aided the accused or interfered with the evidence. It is expected that the results of polygraph tests will shed further illumination and assist the investigators in determining if these individuals are telling the truth.
The Role of Dr. Sandip Ghosh
In a switcheroo, the CBI also requested authorisation to give Dr. Sandip Ghosh, the former head of the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital, a polygraph. Due to his involvement in the ensuing episodes, Dr. Ghosh received notice and was ultimately fired from his position. The CBI believes that Dr. Ghosh may have knowledge of the potential for a cover-up, thus they are keen to learn the degree of his participation, if any.
Legal and Ethical Considerations
Occasionally called polygraph examinations, lie detector exams are a contentious piece of technology used in criminal investigations. They are not perfect and are often contested in court because to their dependability problems, even if they might shed light on a suspect’s accuracy. Nonetheless, the tests will be carried out by the CBI once the required court approvals are obtained.
Conclusion: A Case of Unanswered Questions
Several questions persist following the murder of a PGT doctor at RG Kar Medical College. The polygraph examination of Dr. Ghosh and the four hospital staff members may be crucial for exposing the truth as the CBI continues its probe. The public and the medical community closely follow what happened, with the goal of delivering justice to the young doctor whose life was regretfully cut short.
As the CBI pulls the puzzle together, there are likely to be additional findings in the days that follow. The polygraph examinations might also be an important component in how the investigation is conducted.
